The Council ForumTizzy Talk

Welcome Guest! To enable all features please try to register or login.
8 Pages«<678
Options
View
Go to last post Go to first unread
Offline The Author Guy  
#141 Posted : Wednesday, October 14, 2015 4:03:30 PM(UTC)
The Author Guy

Rank: Arch Demon

Groups: Administrators, AoD Beta Demon, ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 3/14/2014(UTC)
Posts: 1,986

Thanks: 174 times
Was thanked: 109 time(s) in 86 post(s)
We are now getting somewhere. You are making a path in the forst.

I actually got more usable information from you this time then in some of the beta. Your advice here on Jenn and Gastrope' was good. I needed more stuff like that. You say cut, I say it's important and I can't cut it, (and I did cut stuff, like the guys on the boat, the roller coaster) so you then say, OK, we can improve it by have them discussing the guys in the grove, etc. That's what I mean.

You are correct on Hilda, I conflated your criticism with some others and the general "lack of Tom" in the first half. To be honest I have trouble remembering what is in current reviews and what was in beta discussion. At some points it becomes a blur.

Dirk is basing this on on the current discussion/and or other public discussions, he was not in the beta program and does not have access to the beta forum.
Offline Dirk Flamberge  
#142 Posted : Thursday, October 15, 2015 2:16:47 AM(UTC)
Dirk Flamberge

Rank: Demon

Groups: ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 2/1/2015(UTC)
Posts: 201

Thanks: 1 times
Was thanked: 2 time(s) in 2 post(s)
Which is funny because I could've sworn i applied for that, but meh, not really complaining at this point since the books out and I like it. Eh?
Offline The Author Guy  
#143 Posted : Thursday, October 15, 2015 3:41:08 PM(UTC)
The Author Guy

Rank: Arch Demon

Groups: Administrators, AoD Beta Demon, ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 3/14/2014(UTC)
Posts: 1,986

Thanks: 174 times
Was thanked: 109 time(s) in 86 post(s)
I thought you had to, I sent out an email at the begining to all users, but might have got spammed.

Once it was live there was a link to click on that gave absolutely no indication of anything and a few hours later you could see the beta forums. Magic is mysterious, I guess. It went on for some time...
Offline Korwin  
#144 Posted : Friday, October 16, 2015 6:19:33 AM(UTC)
Korwin

Rank: Demon

Groups: AoD Beta Demon, Heavenly Host Beta Demons, ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 5/6/2014(UTC)
Posts: 274

Thanks: 2 times
Was thanked: 10 time(s) in 10 post(s)
Originally Posted by: Dirk Flamberge Go to Quoted Post
Which is funny because I could've sworn i applied for that, but meh, not really complaining at this point since the books out and I like it. Eh?


Almost missed the Beta, too
Offline The Author Guy  
#145 Posted : Friday, October 16, 2015 4:51:52 PM(UTC)
The Author Guy

Rank: Arch Demon

Groups: Administrators, AoD Beta Demon, ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 3/14/2014(UTC)
Posts: 1,986

Thanks: 174 times
Was thanked: 109 time(s) in 86 post(s)
Hmm,

Well I will try something different next time, give a lot more heads up as to starting date.

I used the Forum's mass emailer thing. It's really poorly written, when you send the email the entire server bogs down, the site becomes inaccessible for like 15 minutes. There were less than 200 people. That should have been no strain and trivial. I've designed a lot of websites that can email and notify users, emails are very very low overhead things. It should not have bogged down the system and shouldn't have taken much more than a minute or two.

My bet is that they all looked like auto-generated emails (which they sort of were) and so got spammed. I will do something different for the emails next time.

Also, I gotta work on the stupid link button that you click and then wait random numbers of hours to let you in a a Beta Demon. That caused lots of confusion.

T-A-G
Offline Flakes  
#146 Posted : Monday, November 16, 2015 9:07:38 PM(UTC)
Flakes

Rank: Imp

Groups: AoD Beta Demon, Heavenly Host Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 9/30/2014(UTC)
Posts: 62

Was thanked: 2 time(s) in 2 post(s)
What was the problem with Hilda. She was the best part of book 2. She was book 2's Tom. The reason I kept reading. I'm happy with the way things turned out. All too often in self published books you get some uber main character who is over powered, who just breezes through the plot with deus ex machina saves and shallow secondary characters. Terry Mancour and E. william brown are two fine examples of this. They are the Fantasy for the adolescent male who never grew up crowd. Making it not entirely about Tom lessens this. So while some of the other sections are boring as fuck, they are still worthwhile.
Offline The Author Guy  
#147 Posted : Monday, November 16, 2015 10:43:20 PM(UTC)
The Author Guy

Rank: Arch Demon

Groups: Administrators, AoD Beta Demon, ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 3/14/2014(UTC)
Posts: 1,986

Thanks: 174 times
Was thanked: 109 time(s) in 86 post(s)
Not sure what someone thought was wrong with Hilda.

I know a lot of people were impatient with her because there was so much her and so little Tom in the first part and sometimes that lack of Tom got conflated with dislike of Hilda.

But after ironing things out, I'm not seeing anyone really dislike her. They just wanted more Tom at the same time.

I think your point is very valid. Actually DoA is intended as a reaction to that sort of story line you describe. I got tired of reading the same coming of age/conflict story (or clumsy hero saves the day) over and over so many times I decided to try to turn it on its head.

I really love Hilda, she provides a lot of balance; and she is powerful, but reasonable and "human"

I think the biggest thing that (secretly) annoyed people was that it wasn't what they were expecting. And that ticked people off. But again, that's part of the point. If one has read this all before, then what's the point of writing it again?

That was my big thought when I was starting this, most fantasy books became like sitcoms, you only need to look at the title, read the blurb and a few chapters and you know where it's going. I want to put an end to that, but still make it fun.

And my hope is that some of the more boring parts will start to pay off in later volumes. There are some long setup times...but I don't like things just pulled out of thin air to solve a problem 'deus ex machina' style so I have a lot of setup to explain what happens later, some of that, I admit can be less exciting.
Offline whomightub3  
#148 Posted : Thursday, November 19, 2015 3:16:13 PM(UTC)
whomightub3

Rank: Sprite

Groups: Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 5/11/2014(UTC)
Posts: 5

Thanks: 1 times
Originally Posted by: Flakes Go to Quoted Post
What was the problem with Hilda. She was the best part of book 2. She was book 2's Tom. The reason I kept reading. I'm happy with the way things turned out. All too often in self published books you get some uber main character who is over powered, who just breezes through the plot with deus ex machina saves and shallow secondary characters. Terry Mancour and E. william brown are two fine examples of this. They are the Fantasy for the adolescent male who never grew up crowd. Making it not entirely about Tom lessens this. So while some of the other sections are boring as fuck, they are still worthwhile.


If I wanted to watch re-runs of Mr. Roger's Neighborhood so I can learn valuable life lessons, I would do so. Terry Mancour and E. William Brown are both fine writers and know their niche audiences well. The audience wants awesome magic battles in the vein of Buck Rogers, they don't want the plucky underdog or the hero's journey that normally goes with that. No one does. George R.R. Martin writes some wonderful fiction in the area you are looking for, so does Tad Williams. Highly detailed interwoven plots and sub-plots take decades to write correctly, as in the book came out today, sequel comes out 5 to 10 years later. I read the the first two books of the song of ice and fire back to back... 12 to 15 years ago. I don't remember any of the characters, their motivations, convictions, none of it. None. It's like asking me the name of the boy from Indian in the cupboard that I read when I was 8. I don't know and I'm not sure why I should care. I'm sure I'll give a book series with an extremely complex plot a look once it's complete.

I found Hilda to be a fine character, and her journey to be nice. But completely redundant. She was filler. It was like Goku screaming for half an episode to build a sense of awe and suspense, but mainly because they needed to stretch two comics worth of material into 6 episodes. I, personally, liked it. I can plainly see why many would not.
Offline Flakes  
#149 Posted : Thursday, November 19, 2015 3:32:24 PM(UTC)
Flakes

Rank: Imp

Groups: AoD Beta Demon, Heavenly Host Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 9/30/2014(UTC)
Posts: 62

Was thanked: 2 time(s) in 2 post(s)
I think you are over personalizing things. When you say "no one wants" you are basically talking about yourself and maybe a few of your friends. You have no other frames of reference than that.

While I have no interest in watching re-runs of "Mr. Roger's Neighborhood" or "learning valuable life lessons" I am interested in good characters and interesting plot twists. I suppose it is the difference between being a mature reader and an immature one.
Offline whomightub3  
#150 Posted : Sunday, November 22, 2015 1:47:49 PM(UTC)
whomightub3

Rank: Sprite

Groups: Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 5/11/2014(UTC)
Posts: 5

Thanks: 1 times
A mature reader reads more than the first sentence before making a personal attack.

A mature reader doesn't take things too personal.

A mature reader doesn't sit like a hawk poised to strike on internet forums trying to start silly internet fights.

See how I didn't even notice your reply for three days?

I'm separating these sentences out so they are easier to read, I know you need help with that.

Get a freaking hobby, you internet hobo.
Offline Korwin  
#151 Posted : Tuesday, November 24, 2015 2:22:03 PM(UTC)
Korwin

Rank: Demon

Groups: AoD Beta Demon, Heavenly Host Beta Demons, ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 5/6/2014(UTC)
Posts: 274

Thanks: 2 times
Was thanked: 10 time(s) in 10 post(s)
wtf
How was Hilda's part redundant?

and who is taking it to personal?


Ah, Forum as an ignore function...
Offline Rosver  
#152 Posted : Wednesday, February 17, 2016 9:15:07 AM(UTC)
Rosver

Rank: Greater Demon

Groups: Beta Demon, Heavenly Host Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 6/19/2014(UTC)
Posts: 468

Was thanked: 6 time(s) in 6 post(s)
@Flakes
Quote:
What was the problem with Hilda. She was the best part of book 2. She was book 2's Tom.

The problem is, at least for me, is that she has very minor role. Not to mention, she sucks in her role.
And she is far from the best part of the book. That recognition goes to Tom.
Quote:
All too often in self published books you get some uber main character who is over powered, who just breezes through the plot with deus ex machina saves and shallow secondary characters.

And most are just boring, stupid, badly edited, or just plain crap.
Quote:
Making it not entirely about Tom lessens this. So while some of the other sections are boring as fuck, they are still worthwhile.

But Hilda is almost the same. As a saint, she is OP. She breezes through the plot with her saintly powers, many which just pop up (deus ex machina), and she is surrounded by shallow secondary characters.

@The Author Guy
Quote:
Not sure what someone thought was wrong with Hilda.

Well, for me, I have two problems about her. One, she has a very small role. So small that I think she fits more as a minor character than a main one. The second is that her scenes are filled with obnoxious details, especially the wines and food. Almost all of her scene includes her babbling about wines. It was interesting the first time, but it gets old and annoying very quick.
Quote:
I think the biggest thing that (secretly) annoyed people was that it wasn't what they were expecting. And that ticked people off.

That is not exactly it. Heavenly Host is really just not good and I kinda expect it to be good.
Quote:
If one has read this all before, then what's the point of writing it again?

Why not?
Quote:
That was my big thought when I was starting this, most fantasy books became like sitcoms, you only need to look at the title, read the blurb and a few chapters and you know where it's going.

Predictability is not a problem. For example, I love Into the Abyss and I read again and again and again.Its already predictable because of my constant re-reading. I know it inside out but I read it again. Why?
Another would be the Romance genre. Everyone knows how it goes. Then, why is it one of the most profitable of all the genre? Why is the most predictable of all type of stories have the most audience?
Triteness is the problem of these copycats. Instead of creating they own twist and touch, they instead do a very halfhearted and lazy rehash of the original.
Quote:
And my hope is that some of the more boring parts will start to pay off in later volumes. There are some long setup times...but I don't like things just pulled out of thin air to solve a problem 'deus ex machina' style so I have a lot of setup to explain what happens later, some of that, I admit can be less exciting.

The second book essentially bridges the first book to the third book. Instead of telling a story, you are setting things up for the next story. My review is quite spot on. Your enticing us in the first book and you go all out in the third book, but the second book is virtually nothing. It is just a setup, a bridge.

@Korwin
Quote:
How was Hilda's part redundant?

Most of her scenes where she goes info hunting is not really needed (and she is bad at it). Also, so far, she is still not indespensable. She can still be removed in the narrative and the story can still work.
Offline Korwin  
#153 Posted : Wednesday, February 17, 2016 10:55:05 AM(UTC)
Korwin

Rank: Demon

Groups: AoD Beta Demon, Heavenly Host Beta Demons, ITN Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 5/6/2014(UTC)
Posts: 274

Thanks: 2 times
Was thanked: 10 time(s) in 10 post(s)
Originally Posted by: Rosver Go to Quoted Post

@Korwin
Quote:
How was Hilda's part redundant?

Most of her scenes where she goes info hunting is not really needed (and she is bad at it). Also, so far, she is still not indespensable. She can still be removed in the narrative and the story can still work.

Can't agree here, half the book was about the reactions to the battle at the end of Into the Abyss (and yes, I liked to see those reactions. Was enjoying the gloating I did for Tom since he could'nt because not getting Intel about it).

She might not be perfect at Intel gathering, but she's the best the FoL have.
And you can't really blame her, she is learning by doing.
It's not like she has an internship in an spy agency or has an extensive reading habit of spy novels.

By and large I don't understand your dislike.
Yes it was'nt a second 'Into the Abyss', but we (at least I) would'nt want a carbon copy of Into the Abyss.

While I liked the new Star Wars film, while watching. It left an not quite bad or good aftertaste.
Hopefully the next one isn't an carbon copy of 'The Empire Strikes back'.


Going back to the Topic, without Hilda the book would have been poorer. We got an good introduction to the FoL faction.
Shure there where others from the FoL there, but without Hilda we would have gooten an very negative impression. Much more balanced this way.


I also get the Impression, that if TAG say's something is needed as an build up for the next book, you are dismissing it as an irrelevant argument, without merrit?
Offline Rosver  
#154 Posted : Wednesday, February 17, 2016 12:14:41 PM(UTC)
Rosver

Rank: Greater Demon

Groups: Beta Demon, Heavenly Host Beta Demons, Registered, Registered Users, Subscribers
Joined: 6/19/2014(UTC)
Posts: 468

Was thanked: 6 time(s) in 6 post(s)
Quote:
Can't agree here, half the book was about the reactions to the battle at the end of Into the Abyss (and yes, I liked to see those reactions. Was enjoying the gloating I did for Tom since he could'nt because not getting Intel about it)


I'm talking about Hilda's info gathering, not the reactions.

Quote:
She might not be perfect at Intel gathering, but she's the best the FoL have.
And you can't really blame her, she is learning by doing.
It's not like she has an internship in an spy agency or has an extensive reading habit of spy novels.


It is not because she is bad at it. It's because those scenes are not necessary, thus redundant. She just practically rehashes those when she reports in the meetings.

Quote:
By and large I don't understand your dislike.
Yes it was'nt a second 'Into the Abyss', but we (at least I) would'nt want a carbon copy of Into the Abyss.


And, I don't understand your like.

Yes it was'nt a second 'Into the Abyss', but we (at least I) want a proper continuation of the first book, not a hudred pages bridge or setup.

Quote:
While I liked the new Star Wars film, while watching. It left an not quite bad or good aftertaste.
Hopefully the next one isn't an carbon copy of 'The Empire Strikes back'.


At least a proper movie and a proper sequel. It is not a bridge or setup for the next movie.

Quote:
Going back to the Topic, without Hilda the book would have been poorer. We got an good introduction to the FoL faction.
Shure there where others from the FoL there, but without Hilda we would have gooten an very negative impression. Much more balanced this way.


Yes, Hilda makes it less poor, but it still poor nonetheless. As for the impression, it only reflects on Hilda, not on the FoL as a whole.

See it this way, the Nazi would have some good members in its ranks, good people with good heart, in fact, there are; but would those members 'balance' the view on Nazis? Not at all. The action and trait of an individual reflect only on the individual, not the group.

Quote:
I also get the Impression, that if TAG say's something is needed as an build up for the next book, you are dismissing it as an irrelevant argument, without merrit?


I have three things to say for this:

1) I'm not dismissing it. The biggest problem I have with all these setups is that there is no clear indication for what they are setting up for. Example, there is this scene where Hilda fights the beggars. It might fun and interesting, but what is its connection to everything else? Are the Beggars going to the Abyss and fight demons? Will the Beggars become Tom alies? Maybe the Beggars would become saints too. Uhh! I don't know!

Another is this scene (which is present only in beta) where we practically have pages worth of nothing but Jenn and Gastrope having a rollercoaster ride. I don't understand how this rollercoaster is a setup for anything. Any ideas? And there are similar scenes like these.

2) The argument that these stuff are boring is valid. In fact a large part of the book is boring. Say what you want about this, but a boring book is still a boring book no matter how "needed" the setups are.

3) Three, and the most important point: Heavenly Host is just setting things up for the next story instead of telling a story. In fact, you could say, it has no story at all. Lots of things are happening but they are so disconnected that they might as well be in different books. And the worst thing? It takes hundreds of pages for all of this setup crap. The setup is far bigger than the first book. What the hell.

Edited by user Wednesday, February 17, 2016 12:22:17 PM(UTC)  | Reason: Not specified

Users browsing this topic
Guest (2)
8 Pages«<678
Forum Jump  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Notification

Icon
Error


Copyright © 2020. All Rights Reserved.